Who is liable for damages on a company truck?

Discussion in 'Questions From New Drivers' started by Leon Phelps III, Mar 18, 2013.

  1. Leon Phelps III

    Leon Phelps III Light Load Member

    251
    161
    Mar 9, 2013
    Los Ageles, CA
    0
    Scenario.

    I work for a company that has all the "employees" on 1099 but the provide they trucks, routes, loads, and they regulate when you can go home and how long you can drive. Don't you dare refuse a load or they might ignore your calls and leave you stranded in Seattle waiting for fuel.

    1099 Private Contractor.

    Driving a Owner Op's truck that does not belong to the company.

    I believe company provides the insurance.

    I never signed a doc stating I am responsible for damages but yet they are still attempting to take the deductible they had to pay out of my checks because I hit an ELK!


    Am I really financially responsible for their trucks insurance deductible?
     
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. passingthru69

    passingthru69 Road Train Member

    You are really a company driver..
    You posted about the issue before.Turn them in to the labor board, but have all your facts and papers when you do..
    1099 is O/O who can turn down freight. You have the bills of the fuel etc..
    You are really a company driver, no matter how they try and blow smoke up your back side..
     
    striker, Hardlyevr, j3411 and 2 others Thank this.
  4. superpet39

    superpet39 Road Train Member

    1,161
    619
    Jan 27, 2013
    Bay Area California
    0
    I would contact an attorney, Maybe pay the attorney to contact him :biggrin_25524: ;) Because I had a friend that works for FedEx and I think he got into a small accident did a little bit of damage and he was never chased down for a deductible or repair bill. Good luck nonetheless
     
  5. rookietrucker

    rookietrucker Trucker Forum STAFF Staff Member

    10,061
    7,054
    Jul 15, 2007
    TEXAS
    0
    I'm no lawyer but, Unless you signed a document stating you would pay the insurance deductible due to a accident. No, you are not responsible. I would quietly have a attorney review the charges if they persist deducting your pay for it. :biggrin_25525:
     
    superpet39 Thanks this.
  6. Leon Phelps III

    Leon Phelps III Light Load Member

    251
    161
    Mar 9, 2013
    Los Ageles, CA
    0

    Yea, I feel like an employee but I am not. I will have to gather my evidence and proceed.

    What I am most concerned about is am I financially responsible for their truck? By law? Also if I am a private contractor, they can't just deduct what they claim I owe them from my checks. Right?

    I thought only the state and fed can garnish wages. Shouldn't they have to request the money from me out of pocket or sue me in court for the cost if I am responsible?
     
  7. Leon Phelps III

    Leon Phelps III Light Load Member

    251
    161
    Mar 9, 2013
    Los Ageles, CA
    0

    OK! Thanks.
     
  8. CondoCruiser

    CondoCruiser The Legend

    19,726
    18,733
    Apr 18, 2010
    Tennessee
    0
    You fit the definition of an employee of the contractor. Just because he is wrongfully giving you a 1099 doesn't make you a sub-contractor. Unless you signed a pre-employment agreement to pay for damages it is too late for them to back up now. It's also illegal to coerce you into paying or sticking their hand in the cookie jar to satisfy their wants. Who holds the policy has control which deductible he buys. Because he is a cheapy doesn't fall down on you. No you are not responsible. File a complaint with your state's DOL Wage and Hour division. They will set them straight.

    Besides all that hitting an elk is considered an act of god and I wouldn't think a deductible would apply?
     
    RickG Thanks this.
  9. Marlin46

    Marlin46 Medium Load Member

    504
    299
    Mar 17, 2010
    Atlanta, GA
    0
    If you drive a truck for someone who leased that truck on w/ a carrier then technically you work for the guy who owns the truck even though you get paid, dispatched, etc through another company. It would also be the guy who owns the truck is responsible for Physical Damage coverage - the owner may have this coverage through the carrier or he may have purchased it outside the carrier. What is your contract / agreement with the owner of the truck?

    Definitely not a lawyer here either this is just my observation of the situation. IMO it isn't right that they do not pay the share of taxes on you as it appears you are a company driver. The carrier it looks as though the business plan calls for O/O to avoid truck / trailer purchases and / or paying taxes for what should be classified as company drivers.

    There was a recent post on here about a member who had his paycheck garnished for the deductible on a cargo claim in which the t/t were stolen. They found the t/t undamaged so no physical damage claim. Let us know how it turns out.
     
  10. bwaa

    bwaa Light Load Member

    57
    15
    Mar 8, 2013
    0
    You might be. Ask a lawyer as everyone else here suggested. Hope this turns out well for you.
     
  11. ‘Olhand

    ‘Olhand Cantankerous Crusty

    6,647
    15,949
    Jan 18, 2011
    0
    Wait a sec here-?R u sayin YOU damaged a man's truck it someone else hit it?? Maybe im missing something?
     
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.