OK you think so but I'm not.
Never said that.
There is a limitation that the courts have created.
The Supreme Court ruled that administrative inspections do not violate the 4th amendment. They were clear in this decision, the authority who inspects to make sure the regulations are followed can inspect a truck at any time for any reason, but they are limited to the regulations, not to go beyond them - which there is a catch I mentioned and going to expand on.
What is a simple inspection?
Never heard that.
Oh ok, Well ... WRONG.
The state officer who does the inspection has the right to go through your truck within the limits of the regulations that the state has adopted, these are FMCSA regulations which can have stiffer or more stringent regulations.
When they do an inspection, it is an administrative inspection.
They have limitations to how the inspection takes place, they can't go through areas that are not regulated, and they can look at the sleeper, the mattress, and bedding, but others have serious comprehension problems, they are NOT checking to see if the bed is made.
NOPE, that's wrong.
This is a regulation inspection, it is legally called an administrative inspection for a reason.
IF there are drugs that are found during this type of inspection that are on the list of schedule 1 drugs found on the list 21 part 1308.11 that is referenced by 392.4 this can be evidence in a criminal case - period.
This has been held up in court as part of the inspection process under an administrative inspection.
Again this is not a violation of the 4th amendment.
No permission needs to be given - PERIOD. You can not refuse an inspection either, an enforcement officer can make your day a miserable one.
That's right, they are not searching, they are inspecting.
However, the inspection that turns into a search because of evidence due to something that is found is still not a violation of a person's 4th.
True never said it was but it is an administrative inspection and another issue about it, they don't have to have any reason to pull a truck over for an administrative inspection.
Now I went through this crap with two drivers, one pulled a sovereign citizen crap with a judge, I was there in court because I owned the truck. The driver tried to use YouTube videos to reinforce their claim that their 4th was violated, the judge was not having it, he explained everything I explained and a lot more, one is that the youtube "morons" seem not to take on the cases of people who use this argument.
Can law enforcement enter the truck during inspection?
Discussion in 'Questions From New Drivers' started by stacks, Oct 31, 2023.
Page 5 of 12
-
-
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
-
Yep, still can't admit you are wrong. Why am I not surprised. -
About the drug dog trick. They cannot hold you any longer than necessary to complete the reason for the stop. If that dog is 15 minutes away then tell the cops to finish writing the ticket. If they dilly dally on that for the purpose of giving time enough for the dog it is easily thrown out in court.
Accidental Trucker Thanks this. -
-
From 2015. https://thehill.com/regulation/cour...ules-cops-cant-hold-suspects-to-wait-for-dog/ZVar Thanks this. -
When I was a young co*ksure big rigger I was always right. Went to jail to prove it.
Once I figured how the real world worked I understood the cops, regardless of affiliation, are right..even when they're wrong...
We've gotten along now for decades with that logic. -
Tb0n3 Thanks this.
-
Last night I had dinner with a friend who is now a retired Virginia DOT cop. I briefly went over this thread with him as we discussed the procedures as he understood them. He reminded me that in some states DOT cops are NOT general law enforcement officers and can ONLY deal with administrative issues as @Ridgeline spoke about. He then went on to say however that the vast majority of DOT cops nationwide are state-certified cops in ALL matters. I had forgotten about this point. Here is the issue. The side of the road is NOT where you argue with a cop. If a cop messes up you have options later on. Here is where it gets complicated and I really wish people who are not well versed on the finer points of law would stop dispensing legal advice. So the question is "Can a cop enter the truck?" that answer is YES they can. It may not be legal at the time and the cop might well be violating your rights, but what is done is done and you the trucker have a decision to make. Do you hire an Attorney, and take time off the job for hearings, only to find in 90+% of the cases the judge will upon a motion of the defendant toss the case under the doctrine of qualified immunity? I don't like it and my friend had some things to say about my next comment I can't repeat here. The US is slowly sliding into being a police state. Lawmakers and the courts are using the Bill of Rights as
now!bzinger, Bud A., gentleroger and 1 other person Thank this. -
JoeyJunk Thanks this.
-
JoeyJunk, TripleSix, TheLoadOut and 1 other person Thank this.
Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds
Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.
Page 5 of 12