Another CAT C13 with poor fuel mileage. Looking for advice

Discussion in 'Trucks [ Eighteen Wheelers ]' started by RustyBolt, Mar 18, 2015.

  1. RustyBolt

    RustyBolt Road Train Member

    2,073
    3,333
    Feb 21, 2015
    Bement, IL
    0
    OK, I've been running an 05 International 9200 for a bout a month now. It has a C13 Acert, with an Eaton Fuller 10 speed manual. Not sure on the rear gears yet, as the previous owner painted over everything with a thick coat of black paint. It's a mid-roof with the big bunk like found on the 9400. In fact, you'd be hard pressed to find a difference other than the hood.

    The truck has had it's fair share of issues. Most are just the nickle and dime stuff that comes with a used truck with 650,000 miles on it. The ECM going out after a week, that was not a nickle and dime issue. But it's replaced and all is good. Except for the fuel economy.

    I really struggle to get above 6mpg. Most of my loads are on the fairly flat roads of Illinois. Most are under 20,000lbs. And a large portion (maybe 40%) of my miles are empty. I pull a reefer, by the way.

    Now when I say I struggle to get 6mpg. I mean I'm at or below 55 mph ALL the time. Occasionally, I'll run 62 if the wind is at my back and I'm light. I don't run the engine past 1500 rpm. In fact, I rarely get much over 1300 with the exception of 9th (and 10th on times I run 62). 9th I have to go to 1400+ or it drops off too far when going to 10th. The truck just doesn't feel like it's using anywhere near the 430hp it's set at. I came out of a 430hp Mercedes that could just walk away from this one.

    This is the first truck I have owned (as if you couldn't tell). Always before, I dropped it at a shop and told them "This is what it's doing. Fix it. My company will pay for it". Now that I own it, I have to figure out what's wrong and fix it myself (if I can) or find some place to do the work.

    So, if this were your truck, where would you start looking to find problems that affect fuel mileage?


    (A few things that are planned)
    Almost due for a PM (will send oil for analysis)
    Will be having an over head done. (probably gain some there)
    Going to install a boost gauge to compare with what others are getting on their C13 (maybe a boost issue. It spools up. But who knows)

    Any and all help is greatly appreciated.
     
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. Bout Z

    Bout Z Light Load Member

    275
    1,149
    Mar 14, 2015
    so. ohio
    0
    Ecm went out on my '07 9900 c13 last year. Replaced with a new one and the truck was a dog for a few days. I noticed a decline in fuel mileage. Mechanic said that the new ecm, that was picked up at the dealer, was set to factory default settings. Had a computer guy come and retune everything, and all was good. Power came back and fuel mileage is back up around 6.5-7, which is good for the loads I pull and the roads I run. Might be something to look into if you haven't already.
     
    RustyBolt Thanks this.
  4. rickybobby

    rickybobby Road Train Member

    4,843
    6,672
    Jul 10, 2010
    greensboro, nc
    0
    I have a 06 international C13.. Last year I average 6.84 pulling dry van, weight varies. I drive 60 mph, also I have auto. I have not had truck tuned. When I first got truck I was average 5.5-5.8 mpg. I replace clutch and my mph went up. I change the muffler to and Donaldson.
     
    RustyBolt Thanks this.
  5. tnevin225

    tnevin225 Road Train Member

    1,166
    1,601
    Jan 1, 2014
    0
    Who did the ECM? Dealer or CAT,i would get it to a good CAT dealer, there is one in Hammond IN. that I use and thy do good work. You might look into getting a scangauge, You can find them at Lets Truck.com website. Its a great tool and will give you a lot off info about how your truck is performing. Good Luck
     
    RustyBolt Thanks this.
  6. Helowrenchturn2

    Helowrenchturn2 Medium Load Member

    484
    140
    Apr 23, 2013
    0
    I would be looking at all of the plumbing from exhaust manifold to intake manifold first. Any leaks there or in the charge air cooler would likely more than account for poor mpg and low power. If there is a leak the engine has to use more fuel to get enough boost to maintain the same power as one with no leaks. A boost and pyrometer gauge would tell you quite a bit about what the engine is doing also.
     
    RustyBolt Thanks this.
  7. RustyBolt

    RustyBolt Road Train Member

    2,073
    3,333
    Feb 21, 2015
    Bement, IL
    0
    Bout Z: Thanks for the reply. I took the truck to The Diesel Doctor in Effingham, IL. They were the ones who found the error codes that led to the replacement of the ECM. Maybe I'll swing back down there and see what they can do with it now.

    tenevin225: Thanks for the reply. I had Altorfer in Champaign, IL do the work on my ECM. There was, also, a bad oil pressure senser and one bad Intake Valve Actuator that they replaced. I've not heard anything bad about their work. But, on the other hand, I haven't heard anything good, either. I took some time to look into the scangauge you mentioned. Will do some serious thinking on that. Looks like it could be very beneficial for no more than it costs. Thanks again!

    Helowrenchturn2: I will check into your suggestion as well. I was told that, if there were problems in the past, there could also be build up inside the plumbing that could cause power loss. Not sure what those problems could be. Or if the truck ever had any of those issues. I didn't get much info from the place I got it from. International and CAT didn't have much history on it in their systems either. So, guessing it was pretty much maintained by in house mechanics.

    If anyone else wants to chime in, I'm all ears. Well, seeing as this is the internet, I'm all eyes.:biggrin_25526:
     
  8. RustyBolt

    RustyBolt Road Train Member

    2,073
    3,333
    Feb 21, 2015
    Bement, IL
    0
    I followed up on tenevin225's advice and ended up getting a ScanGauge. I hooked it up today for the first time and was given some data that has been troubling me.

    I didn't get into the whole fuel tank size mpg stuff today. I just wanted to see how certain aspects were (or were not) performing.

    The fist one I was interested in is the boost. This one really bugs me. It goes up to 31.5 and stops dead in it's tracks. I can back out of the throttle and let the boost come down to 25 or so. Then mash the throttle and it will shoot right up to 31.5psi. No 31.6 and then drop to 31.5. Just 31.5 and done.

    The other is the horsepower. The ScanGauge is reporting that my horsepower is roughly 320@1600+-. That was with a 12k in the reefer up hill in ninth gear with my foot on the back of the engine. I know that's not how to drive a CAT but wanted to see what numbers I could get.

    What could cause the boost pressure to stop right at the same 31.5psi over and over again?
    I'm assuming the lack of boost is why the low HP numbers too. The truck ECM is set to 430hp.
    No error codes, by the way.

    Thanks for any suggestions/advice.
     
  9. RustyBolt

    RustyBolt Road Train Member

    2,073
    3,333
    Feb 21, 2015
    Bement, IL
    0
    Well, I've been searching the web for info on the issues I'm having with lack of turbo pressure and low horsepower. And I think I have come across some info that may lead to a solution.

    I read a page by a CAT Master mechanic where he stated that the ECM on this engine does not throw an error due to low fuel pressure. It merely recognizes the fact that the motor is starving and cuts the boost and horsepower to compensate.

    It was suggested to start with changing the fuel filters. My truck is about due for a PM anyway. However, it's been sluggish since the last PM when the filters were replaced then. So, I am going to skip that and go straight to the pressure test. If the pressure test shows there is low pressure, I will change the filters and retest.

    If there is still a pressure issue, I will need to dig into the fuel lines to see if there is any blockage, kinked lines, etc. I've never messed with this stuff on a truck, but I am guessing there would be a "pick up" (or 2) that could be clogged.

    He then suggested replacing the pressure regulator as they have been known to have issues. It's, also, much cheaper to replace than the fuel pump. Which would come next.

    I'll update this as I find out more in hopes that it will help someone in the future.

    If anyone has any tips for my endeavour, I'd be very appreciative.
     
    JRodr and Bout Z Thank this.
  10. walrus

    walrus Bobtail Member

    6
    1
    Jul 15, 2013
    0
    Your complaint could just be a low torque setting on the ecm. If you're geared according to the CAT recommended setting for a C-13 at 1650 torque, but the previous owner set your engine to 1550, it will not perform. Your torque setting is just as important as your HP setting if not more so.

    C13
    ON-HIGHWAY

    DIESEL ENGINE — 335 to 470 hp


    The C13 On-Highway Diesel Engine offers a wide operating range and high torque rise, which promotes the use of transmissions with fewer gears. Even with this built-in feature, heavy/specialty haulers must remember their trucks should be geared to achieve the appropriate compromise between startability and desired road speed. The general principal drivers should follow is that of the “gear fast, run slow” strategy to achieve optimal performance. For the best balance of performance and fuel economy, spec axle ratios and tire sizes according to the following: 80,000 lb GCW or less 430-hp, 1650 lb-ft:1450 rpm @ 65 mph.

    Any CAT dealer will be able to take your engine serial number and tell you what your torque is set to. This is a simple call to make to any CAT service department. If you don't use an authorized dealer, tell a friend to make the call for you. It will only take the service rep about 1 minute to look up this information. If you're set at 1550 and running close to 1450 rpm's at 65 in top gear, then you will need to increase your torque to 1650 to gain fuel economy and power.

    If the previous owner geared your truck incorrectly, you'll probably have to find a private tuner to program your C-13 correctly. Most CAT dealers will not increase your torque to 1650 if your transmission and clutch are only rated to 1550 (which will be the case if your engine was set to 1550 at the factory).
     
    RustyBolt Thanks this.
  11. RustyBolt

    RustyBolt Road Train Member

    2,073
    3,333
    Feb 21, 2015
    Bement, IL
    0
    I have pages and pages of info printed from CAT when they changed my ECM. Nothing states exactly what the torque is set at. Just "Rated Peak Torque: 1550/1750 @ 1200rpm". That may well be part of the whole fuel economy deal. But I'm sure not being ale to access all my horsepower is part of it too. Especially when it takes 2 miles to get 25000lbs up to 62mph because the truck wont make over 275hp and gets 2mpg while doing it.


    The truck goes in this Thursday to get the exhaust manifold replaced. I found a crack in it while doing my pretrip. I would change it myself. But I'm not set up to deal with broken bolts. Which, I'm sure there will be at least one. Always seems to be that way. If that repair isn't too pricey, I'm having the overhead done too. I will see if they can give me any more info on the current setup. I, also, plan to have them do a fuel pressure test. As, I really think that is where my horsepower/turbo issue is stemming from.
     
    Last edited: Apr 7, 2015
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.