Alternative to Central Dispatch??

Discussion in 'Car Hauler and Auto Carrier Trucking Forum' started by lockmedic, May 10, 2016.

  1. lockmedic

    lockmedic Bobtail Member

    6
    4
    May 9, 2016
    0
    I always call past transporters directly if I have something along their route (assuming I know it. . I always ask). Better for both parties, really.

    So I take it there's room in the market for competition for CD?

    What are they charging transporters? From what I've heard it's something like a minimum of $60/mo for a certain no. of "leads" (loads from a state/to a state you specify) which you're expected to call the dealer to grab the load, and so it winds up being a hassle for both sides?

    Anyone willing to post some screen captures of how the transporter side of various load boards are set up?
     
  2. Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.

  3. lockmedic

    lockmedic Bobtail Member

    6
    4
    May 9, 2016
    0
    Yeah I'd considered that already. Hardest part will be getting a large enough nucleus of dealers/transporters initially for a critical mass. Gotta have both for it to work. . . I have some thoughts on how to reach out to both effectively but I don't really want to post that information publicly. Suffice to say if it gets off the ground there will be an initial period of time where it's free for both sides. Early adopter bonus, if you will.

    The logic being if it costs you nothing to sign up, you probably would.
     
    DrDieselUSA and clara Thank this.
  4. lockmedic

    lockmedic Bobtail Member

    6
    4
    May 9, 2016
    0
    So how would you transporters like for your end to work?

    Ideas I've already come up with include searching loads by distance from a zip or city rather than a whole state, possibly search for loads along a specified distance from a corridor (i.e. 'find loads within 50 miles of I81 between TN and NJ). I'm told that will be a complex feature to implement. "Oak Ridge PhD level math" is what one of my devs compared it to.

    I like 1D's pricing structure where transporters can "take it now" or "make an offer", so you can always ask for more electronically without having to call anybody. I'd improve on that by allowing both parties to negotiate electronically. . . so if you're looking at a load that's being offered for $200, you can offer to do it for $250, the seller can counter at $225, no need to call.

    Service would be charged based on accepted loads, not "leads".

    Phone/tablet app would be ideal as well (so you guys/gals can search for loads from the cab of your truck without getting out the laptop) but depends on development cost. May not be available on the initial rollout.
     
  5. brian991219

    brian991219 Road Train Member

    2,924
    5,816
    Aug 10, 2013
    Lords Valley, PA
    0
    Pretty much all the features I need right there, especially the lane search. Free until you accept a load is fair, just make it a reasonable percentage of the load cost, for example on one side of RAT I pay 10%, actually since I am a auction direct carrier Ready extorted 10% out of us by cutting it out of our previously negiotated contract rates, but since I am a preferred carrier I use the other side of Ready for free. If you were to ask for say 3-5% of the load from whichever party initiated the contact (i.e. if a carrier post an available truck or a shipper post an available load) that would be more than reasonable. Also, clear info on the condition of the unit, example inop could be total loss salvage that needs a forklift and a roll back or could be not road worthy but lot drivable or no keys, so it would stop a lot of unnecessary declining or canceling of loads if we had accurate info so as not to bid in the first place.
     
  6. lockmedic

    lockmedic Bobtail Member

    6
    4
    May 9, 2016
    0
    On the dealer side, 1D charged by mileage range. 1,000 mi haul was $10/car, 500 mi was about $6, that sort of thing. Interesting to hear that RAT was potentially charging you guys more than the shippers.

    I had figured more of a flat rate, as realistically it's the same amount of work on the part of the website if it's a $200 haul bill or a $1,000 haul bill. . and I do like the idea of only charging the side that initiated the transaction, or at least bias the bill in that direction.

    And yes, absolutely on the condition issue. I buy a lot of stuff from Copart and am as explicit as possible when describing what I bought. Problem is I don't actually see them until they show up, so I have to go off photos and Copart's description of damage, which is 2 lines in the vehicle attributes (primary damage, secondary damage, and usually vague like 'front' or "undercarriage'). One thing that we could probably do is link to the lots at their respective auctions so the carriers have the same photos the buyers have. . . easy to do with Copart and IAA, don't know about Manheim/Adesa, but as they primarily sell runs/drives stuff it hopefully won't be as big of an issue.

    1D had the ability to upload docs/photos, which I did, but 90% of the time the carriers never looked at them. Most transporters showed up with 3-4 car wedge trailers with one guy driving and a wife at home scouring load boards (presumably), and the wife didn't always share the full info package with hubby so there were a few surprises. . .mostly stuff like flat tires or dead engines. Don't really know how to prevent that other than make it mobile/tablet friendly so hopefully hubby will log in and check for himself.
     
    DrDieselUSA and brian991219 Thank this.
  7. wyodispatchgirl

    wyodispatchgirl Light Load Member

    75
    27
    Feb 26, 2016
    Western Slopes of Colorado
    0
    I just logged into 1D and it was not shut down...
     
  8. Ryan S2016

    Ryan S2016 Medium Load Member

    450
    301
    Feb 11, 2016
    Western North Carolina
    0
    I use CD every day it's my primary shipping site for finding loads. Used to be on U-Ship but personally feel they are a waste of time. People on there want their stuff shipped for practically nothing, and having to fight with large brokers and Freight Forwarders is a bit much for a small company like myself. Most of the time when I deliver or pickup they ask me for a Biz card so they can avoid CD fees. So far not to many return calls. My only issue is these reviews that some companies want to see tons of. Like CarsArrive and Auto Transport.com. Its a bit much if you ask me but is what it is. I just think paying $90 a month for access to view loads is a bit much but on the other side CD doesn't charge a broker fee like U-Ship. Just wish there was another board besides CD I could find more work for.
     
    DrDieselUSA Thanks this.
  9. jeffman164

    jeffman164 Medium Load Member

    594
    557
    Dec 4, 2012
    0
    1D still working over here .
     
  10. Ryan S2016

    Ryan S2016 Medium Load Member

    450
    301
    Feb 11, 2016
    Western North Carolina
    0
    could you send me the link to the site when you get a chance. Thank You
     
  11. clara

    clara Light Load Member

    112
    82
    May 3, 2016
    0
    Uship gives them an average quote before they post I think. They forget to take into account their own fee...so then the loads get cheaper and cheaper. Montway is a big one that takes almost every serious customer from Uship and of course they have their own fee. I get they're not in it for love, love doesn't pay their bills any more than it pays mine lol!
    Reviews, where do you mean? On CD, Uship, or just out there on the web for any average Joe to see?
     
  • Truckers Report Jobs

    Trucking Jobs in 30 seconds

    Every month 400 people find a job with the help of TruckersReport.